Come in and check out our selection of traditional baking including pies, quiche, pizza, scotch eggs, custard slice, apple shortcake, loaves, biscuits, strudel, carrot cake, apple turnovers, cream cakes, cheesecake, tarts, and that’s just to name a few. Our bakers love to try new things too!
Steak, bacon, cheese & onion.
Just as it says - yummy!
In a creamy mushroom & bacon sauce.
Slowly roasted and served in decadent gravy complimented with our apple sauce.
In a creamy Indian sauce.
In a creamy sauce with kumara & pumpkin, encased in spinach pastry.
Slow cooked tender steaks with rich gravy & herbs.
Our hearty beef served with a tasty sweet onion marmalade.
Mushrooms lightly sautéed in a creamy garlic & butter sauce accompanied by our hearty beef.
For all you crazy Mexicans! Spicy chilli mince with red kidney beans, calmed to taste with cheese & sour cream.
Tasty lambs liver sautéed with bacon & onions in a rich tomato gravy.
Slowly braised rich venison, complimented with our homemade whisky relish.
As close to Cornwall as you can get in NZ! With mince, carrot, potato & more.
Baker’s creation of the week to give our regulars something different - maybe you could even suggest one!
For speciality cakes made to order, please contact us to speak to one of our bakers for options & a quote. Orders need to be placed 24 hours prior to pickup. Speciality, novelty or edible image orders need to be placed seven days before the day you need your cake.
All prices include Writing on Cakes if desired, we can also supply birthday candles for a small charge.
All cake orders require 24 hours notice.
Check out our facebook page for festive cakes available for Christmas , Easter & Mother & Fathers Day
Light mouth watering chocolate or plain sponge layered with freshly whipped Plain or Chocolate Cream, or butter cream. Choose from Cherry, Strawberry or Raspberry. Gluten Free available.
We make a variety of cheesecake flavours - just enquire with one of our friendly staff for our list of flavours.
Our famous spiced, sweet moist carrot cake is a beautiful variation for a cake for a special occasion, iced with our smooth cream cheese icing you can’t go wrong!
Traditional moist chocolate cake covered in our creamy chocolate ganache and decorated for your special occasion. Let us know if you want to add a special message on top.
Thanks for checking out our catering option. We would love to help you out with your next event to make your catering easy and food amazing! We can design customised catering to suit your needs. Please see our options designed with a variety of events in mind, as well as our favourite catering options available in bulk. Once you’ve decided what you’d like just come in and see one of our friendly team at one of our two stores, or see our contact page to call or e-mail us. 24 hours notice is preferred.
Terms & Conditions
We require 24 hours notice on catering orders
** There will be a small charge for boxes and serving trays, customers are welcome to bring in their own clean containers/platters for us to pack their products into.
Ideal for anniversaries, celebrations or funerals.
Want to impress the family or give a gift to some friends? Grab one of our Carry us home Pie Packs! Our best deal for bulk buying and the best 12 pack you can get! Select from our options below...
Conditions of Pie Packs: Mixed packs must only contain 6 gourmet or low gluten pies, pie packs are not to be used in conjunction with our loyalty programme, flavours cannot be exchanged once packed, Sheffield Pies are not responsible for the reheating, storage or damaging of products once they have left the store.
Please note all of our products are manufactured on plant that handles wheat, soy, egg, tree nut, seed and milk products.
Nutritional and allergy information is available on request.
Please safely reheat your pies. Heat at 150°C for 15-20 minutes until centre of pie is 75°C. Enjoy!
Low Gluten Pie Selection available. Contact store for available flavours. For best results with our low gluten pastry heat pies from
frozen in the microwave upside down for 2 minutes, flip right side up and heat for a further 1 1/2 to 2 mins until the centre reaches
75 degrees. Enjoy!
Take home a pie selection or one of our family-sized pies for the freezer!
We can help you cater for those special occasions. Simply make your selections from our catering menu and we can provide the food for you to place straight on the table for your guests to enjoy. We have plenty of options to choose from. Please call or email our catering managers on firstname.lastname@example.org for any help and suggestions.
We bake a variety of cakes to suit most occasions. Check our cake menu for delicious flavours like chocolate, carrot and cream gateaux. We can also make cakes to order, please call or email to discuss your needs.